Ultimate Guide: Belt Bags vs. Fanny Packs
What goes around comes right back around. That's rule No. 1 when it comes to fashion. So, it shouldn't be surprising that fanny packs have also made quite a comeback in recent years. Better yet, they didn't come back alone. They've also evolved into the oh-so-modern belt bags. So, is that it? Are belt bags just fanny packs with a modern twist? Not quite.
Sure, both bags share the much-beloved versatility and practicality. However, there are distinct features that set them apart. With this in mind, let's dive into the belt bag vs. fanny pack debate and define what makes each contender unique.
Understanding Belt Bags and Fanny Packs
If we have any chance of untangling the belt bag vs. fanny pack web, we must first cover the bases. This entails answering two questions. What are these bags, and how did they come to be?
Definition and Design
If you've seen a single photo from the ‘90s (or lived through the era), you likely don't need much introduction to the fanny pack. But let's not take any chances.
A fanny pack is a small pouch that is typically worn lower on the hips. For the most part, this bag is perceived as strictly practical. It's the kind of bag you'd associate with tourists, joggers, or anyone needing quick access to the essential key-phone-wallet combo.
As for the belt bag, it represents the modern evolution of the fanny pack (as previously mentioned). While it shares the same basic concept—a small, hands-free pouch attached to an adjustable strap—the belt bag is often viewed as a more stylish and versatile option. It's also typically worn higher on the body (around the waist) and can even transform into a sling bag. As such, a belt bag is typically more of a fashion statement.
Of course, there are also belt bags that offer the best of both worlds. Just take the iconic Lululemon Everywhere Belt Bag as an example. Sport this bag, and you get it all – fashion and function.
Historical Context
Believe it or not, the history of the fanny pack stretches back much further than the '90s. While the modern version did gain popularity in the late 20th century, the concept of a small, belt-attached pouch actually has ancient roots. For example, Ötzi the Iceman—a well-preserved natural mummy from around 3300 B.C.—was found with a belt pouch considered to be an ancient precursor to the fanny pack.
Given that humans have long had the need for a small pouch for carrying daily essentials, it shouldn't be surprising that fanny packs have always found a way to adapt (and endure) through the ages.
That's how the belt bag came to be. Blending historical utility with contemporary aesthetics, this bag has made fanny packs all the rage once again. If you want to see what this blend looks like in practice, just check out the Herschel Seventeen Hip Pack. This bag is the perfect example of a classic fanny pack with a modern twist.
Key Differences Between Belt Bags and Fanny Packs
You can probably already tell the key differences between the fanny pack and the belt bag from their definition (and history) alone. However, let's break them down further to make things crystal clear.
Placement and Fit
First things first, a fanny pack and a belt bag will be positioned differently on your torso. The fanny pack will hang lower on the hips, often nearing your thighs or rear. In contrast, you'd wear a belt bag closer to your waist, often cinching it just like a belt. Not sure what this looks like in person? Just look for one of the many incredible fashionistas wearing the Gucci GG Marmont Matelassé Belt Bag, a high-end belt bag that often replaces a belt.
Material and Style
Since fanny packs were primarily designed for practicality, not much thought was put into the appearance of their fabric. All that mattered was that the fabric in question was affordable, durable, easy to clean, and water-resistant. That's why common materials used for fanny packs include nylon, polyester, and canvas. This practice remains prevalent today, with one of the most popular sporty fanny packs—the Adidas Originals National Waist Pack—made with recycled polyester.
On the other hand, belt bags are all about style. That's why high-end materials like genuine and vegan leather are often involved in their production. The same goes for designer fabrics like luxe canvas.
Since a more significant emphasis is placed on the design of a belt bag, these bags will also come in a wider array of styles, colors, and shapes.
Functionality and Use
Now, no one is saying that belt bags are used only for their aesthetic. However, it's also undeniable that they are more commonly viewed (and used) as fashion accessories.
On the other hand, with fanny packs, it's not about how these bags look. It's about how well they can serve you: the number of additional pockets on the outside, the available space, the number of functional accessories like key clips and mesh fabric pouches — and the list can go on and on!
Styling Tips for Belt Bags and Fanny Packs
Now that you know what fanny packs and belt bags are, let's see how you can best style them.
Casual Outfits
There's no doubt about it – a fanny pack and a casual outfit are a match made in heaven. Just pop on the Nike Heritage Hip Pack over a relaxed pair of jeans and a comfy T-shirt, and you'll look oh-so-cool. For a more chic look, swap the fanny pack with a striking belt bag and usher in your model-off-duty era!
Business and Formal Attire
Use a belt bag to break up a monochromatic jumpsuit or dress and voilà – you've added visual interest to your outfit! If you want to go for the fanny pack instead, you still can. Just opt for a black fanny pack with a sleek design to keep up with the overall theme.
Travel and Outdoor Activities
A fanny pack can be a lifesaver during your travels or outdoor activities. Simply pair a bag with your favorite hiking pants and a fun tee, and you're good to go.
Do you prefer to travel in style? No problem! Just use a belt bag instead of the fanny pack. But beware. Making this swap also means you won't be able to fit as many personal items. However, you can always carry a handy black sling bag or a black tote bag on the side. After all, they go with everything!
Choosing the Right Bag for Your Needs
OK, by now, you've got all the facts. Now, it's time to make a choice. Here's how to do it.
Assessing Your Lifestyle
When it comes to choosing any functional bag, such as a women's toiletry bag or a carry-on, there's one question to ask yourself – how much will you use it? The more often you need the bag, the more spacious and functional it should be.
As for belt bags, they're ideal for individuals who value style over functionality and will generally use them less frequently.
Evaluating Comfort and Fit
The belt bag vs. fanny pack choice can boil down to a simple question – which style fits you better? People with thicker waistlines will enjoy fanny packs more, as they won't create an awkward bulge when worn. On the other hand, belt bags, typically worn higher on the waist might suit those who prefer a more streamlined look.
Matching With Your Wardrobe
Your bag of choice should always complement your personal style color and design-wise. Why? Because a well-chosen bag can make any outfit more cohesive.
Of course, you can always experiment, as well. Try different styles until you find the one that suits you the best. In this regard, you'll probably have more luck with the belt bags. After all, they offer way more colors and styles than fanny packs. You can also use your luggage as a style guide. For example, a hanging black women's toiletry bag in your luggage calls for a matching black fanny pack.
The Choice Is Yours
Only one thing matters – which style of bag do you prefer? Share your answers in the comments section below. While you're there, toss in a few of your experiences with different bags, such as tote bags and carry-on bags. Our newsletter is always at your service if you lack experience but want to learn more.
FAQs
Are belt bags and fanny packs the same thing?
No, belt bags and fanny packs aren't the same thing. Sure, they share the same basic premise. However, they differ in placement, construction, and functionality.
Can you wear a fanny pack as a belt bag?
If the adjustable shoulder strap allows it, absolutely!
What is the new name for a fanny pack?
Belt bag. Waist bag. Belt pack. Those are just some of the new names for a fanny pack.
What do the British call fanny packs?
In Britain, a fanny pack is known as a bum bag.